Hobby Lobby: 6 must-buy finds and 6 items to avoid, according to reviews

Show summary Hide summary

• Top Hobby Lobby picks reviewers recommend for home and craft projects
  • Whimsical pre-lit Christmas tree that reviewers love
  • Kona Coffee Tin Candle — a crowd-pleasing scent
  • Vintage Flowers tapestry for neutral, calming wall decor
  • Sculpey Premo oven-bake clay — a reliable crafting staple
  • Shaggy Faux Fur Berber throw for comfort and cozy style
  • Velvet round pillow that adds color and shape
• Hobby Lobby items reviewers frequently advise skipping
  • Brittany Pine pre-lit tree — complaints about lights and price
  • Ridged ultrasonic aroma diffuser — common functionality failures
  • Brown and cream flower scroll knob — pretty but fragile
  • Wood bird feeder kit — assembly and material issues
  • Burlap “Merry Christmas” garland — watch for spelling errors
  • Wood shadow box — fragile finish and depth issues

Hobby Lobby draws bargain hunters, crafters, and home decorators with rows of seasonal décor, crafting supplies, and quirky finds. Shoppers praise some products and warn against others. We sifted through customer feedback to pinpoint which items are reliably good — and which tend to disappoint. Below are crowd-tested picks and cautionary flags to help you shop smarter.

Top Hobby Lobby picks reviewers recommend for home and craft projects

Whimsical pre-lit Christmas tree that reviewers love

Shoppers looking for a festive, playful tree often choose the Whimsical Pre-lit Christmas Tree. It comes in three heights and has a curved top for a fun silhouette. Reviewers report strong satisfaction and frequent praise for appearance and ease of use.

• Why buy: Very high customer rating and appealing shape.
• Best for: Small spaces, tabletop displays, and nontraditional holiday styling.
• Tip: Measure ceiling height if you opt for the tallest size.

Kona Coffee Tin Candle — a crowd-pleasing scent

The Kona Coffee Tin Candle gets repeat mentions for an authentic coffee aroma and retro packaging. Buyers like both scent throw and the nostalgic canister design.

• Why buy: Strong scent profile that smells like brewed coffee.
• Design note: Vintage-style tin doubles as decor after burning.
• Tip: If you prefer subtle fragrances, test in-store first.

Vintage Flowers tapestry for neutral, calming wall decor

This floral tapestry appeals to people who want a subtle, aged look. Many reviewers praised the muted tones and the included wood slats that frame the piece.

• Why buy: High positive review volume and versatile colors.
• Best placement: Living rooms, bedrooms, or entryways with neutral palettes.
• Tip: Check dimensions; larger rooms need a larger tapestry to avoid looking lost on the wall.

Sculpey Premo oven-bake clay — a reliable crafting staple

Artists and hobbyists consistently recommend Sculpey Premo for its pliability and color options. Many users cite ease of conditioning and good results when cured properly.

• Why buy: Strong reviews for workability and color mixing.
• Best for: Jewelry making, small sculptures, and mixed-media projects.
• Tip: Follow baking instructions closely to avoid brittleness.

Shaggy Faux Fur Berber throw for comfort and cozy style

Customers frequently call this throw “super soft” and buy multiples for gifts. The neutral colors blend with many styles and reviewers often repurchase.

• Why buy: Soft texture and flattering neutral hues.
• Care note: Follow washing instructions to keep pile intact.
• Tip: Buy extras at sale price — many shoppers report gifting them.

Velvet round pillow that adds color and shape

This round velvet cushion wins points for style and support. Most buyers find it attractive and comfortable, though a few mention the decorative button may loosen over time.

• Why buy: Color options and solid support for a sofa or chair.
• Watch for: Occasional reports of buttons detaching.
• Tip: Reinforce the central button if you want extra durability.

Hobby Lobby items reviewers frequently advise skipping

Brittany Pine pre-lit tree — complaints about lights and price

Despite its upscale price tag, many buyers report lighting failures and out-of-box defects. Several long-term reviews say significant portions of the lights failed within a year.

• Why skip: Repeated reports of faulty or dead lights.
• Price concern: High cost with widespread negative feedback.
• Tip: If tempted, test lights immediately and keep the receipt for returns.

Ridged ultrasonic aroma diffuser — common functionality failures

Customers who bought this diffuser often say it never produced mist or broke quickly. Many reviewers report only the LED lights worked and found assembly or instructions lacking.

• Why skip: Frequent reports of no mist and short lifespan.
• What to expect: Some units may function only as nightlights.
• Tip: Consider higher-rated diffusers with clear warranty support.

Brown and cream flower scroll knob — pretty but fragile

These decorative knobs attract attention for their design but fall short on durability. Buyers describe knobs separating from their bases or sliding off.

• Why skip: Structural weakness and poor mounting integrity.
• Alternative: Look for solid metal or sealed ceramic hardware.
• Tip: If you buy, test one before committing to multiple pieces.

Wood bird feeder kit — assembly and material issues

DIY fans report bent nails, splitting wood, and confusing instructions. The finished feeder can be cute, but many say construction problems make it a headache.

• Why skip: Inconsistent hardware and fragile wood.
• DIY option: Use reclaimed materials for a sturdier build.
• Tip: If you attempt the kit, have extra nails and glue on hand.

Burlap “Merry Christmas” garland — watch for spelling errors

Several buyers received garlands with misspellings. While the garland is charming, inconsistent quality control has led to multiple reports of wrong letters.

• Why skip: Risk of receiving a misspelled banner.
• What to do: Inspect product immediately and keep packaging for returns.
• Tip: Buy only from sellers with easy returns or check in-store stock.

Wood shadow box — fragile finish and depth issues

Customers often find the paint chips easily and some items arrive cracked. Many also note the interior is very deep, which can make displayed objects harder to see.

• Why skip: Reports of damage during shipping and thin paint finish.
• Fit concern: Deep boxes may hide smaller keepsakes.
• Tip: Inspect for cracks and consider framing alternatives for small objects.