Show summary Hide summary
Consumer Reports has shaken up the familiar grill aisle this year by naming a less-expected brand its top midsize gas grill for 2026. Rather than the usual Weber or Ninja front-runners, a Napoleon model rose to the top after tests that focused on cooking performance and owner satisfaction.
Why the Napoleon Rogue Pro 425 stands out in 2026 grill tests
Michaels holiday finds under $25: 20 new gifts that look like $50
Target wall-mounted find frees up countertop space: timeless style for small kitchens
The Napoleon Rogue Pro 425 SIB (RP425SIBPK-2) won CR’s highest overall score in the midsize gas grill category. Testers praised its balanced combination of searing power, heat control, and usability. Runners-up included a Ninja FlexFlame model and the Weber Genesis, but Napoleon edged them out with consistent results across key measures.
Features that matter for backyard cooks
- Main cooking area: About 425 square inches of porcelain-coated cast-iron surface.
- Burner layout: Three primary gas burners that deliver wide heat coverage.
- Ignition: A battery-free ignitor for reliable starts.
- Grate design: A grid-style cooking surface meant to keep food from falling through.
- Infrared side burner: Built for high-heat searing and quick browning.
- Night use: Lighted control knobs for easier adjustments after dark.
- Versatility: Can be used for searing, roasting, and low-and-slow smoking.
- Price range: Listed around $971 at retailers like BBQ Guys and Amazon at the time of review.
How Consumer Reports arrived at the ranking
CR’s grill evaluations weigh both objective lab measurements and cooking tests. The most influential categories were temperature range, preheat speed, indirect-cooking ability, and how evenly the grill distributes heat. Those metrics determine how well a grill performs across a variety of recipes.
Napoleon scored perfectly in temperature range and indirect cooking, and posted very high marks for heat evenness and preheat time. The Ninja FlexFlame showed slightly faster preheat in tests, while the Weber Genesis did not produce any perfect category scores. Customer satisfaction and brand dependability also factored into the final placement.
Owner feedback: real-world praise and common complaints
Online reviewers generally commended the Rogue Pro for strong searing and a premium feel. Many owners appreciated the infrared side burner and the grill’s adaptability for different cooking styles.
- Positives: Excellent searing performance, sturdy build, and solid warranty support.
- Negatives: Some users reported food sticking to grates despite the grid design.
- Durability notes: A number of buyers said components failed after a few years, prompting frustration.
- Assembly and shipping: Complaints included tricky instructions and arriving parts with dents.
- Warranty reassurance: The model carries a 15-year warranty, which eased buyer concerns for many.
Practical tips before you buy
- Compare prices across major retailers and watch for seasonal sales.
- Inspect parts on delivery and photograph any shipping damage before assembly.
- Register the product to activate warranty coverage and keep receipts.
- Follow manufacturer instructions for seasoning cast-iron grates to reduce sticking.
- Learn simple grill-cleaning steps to extend component life and maintain heat performance.
- Match grill size and cooking area to your usual meal planning and patio space.
What to expect in everyday use
Owners who cook frequently will value the Rogue Pro’s strong sear and flexible cooking zones. For occasional users, the battery-free ignitor and clear controls simplify routine grilling. Expect that assembly will take time and patience, and that you may want basic tools on hand to straighten or adjust parts that arrive imperfect.
