Show summary Hide summary
For homeowners with large lawns, a riding mower can transform a weekend chore into a fast, manageable task. Consumer Reports’ latest rankings for 2026 shine a light on which machines deliver lasting performance and why the John Deere X354 earned top honors this year.
Who topped Consumer Reports’ 2026 riding mower list
Consumer Reports evaluated 13 riding mowers in 2026. The organization combined hands-on testing with feedback from more than 39,000 members to produce its ratings. At the top of the list sat the John Deere X354, which received an overall score of 84.
Michaels holiday finds under $25: 20 new gifts that look like $50
Target wall-mounted find frees up countertop space: timeless style for small kitchens
CR highlighted the X354’s strengths in core mowing tasks, noting near-perfect results in bagging, mulching, cutting evenness, handling, and side discharge.
John Deere’s strong showing across categories
John Deere did more than claim the top spot. Several of its models placed high on the list, showing the brand’s continued dominance in the U.S. market for lawn equipment.
- John Deere S240-48 — tied near the top with an 84 rating.
- John Deere X350-42 — close behind with an 83 score.
- John Deere S170 — also ranked, with a score around 80.
Beyond conventional riding mowers, John Deere was named the top brand for zero-turn mowers, beating competitors like Kubota and Club Cadet in consumer ratings.
Why the X354 stands out for everyday users
Testers praised the X354 for the quality of its cut and user-friendly controls. Owners who are new to ride-on equipment will find the machine approachable.
- Smooth discharge and minimal clumping — clippings spread evenly when not bagging.
- Even, consistent cuts — minimal dips and a professional-looking finish.
- Comfort and convenience — cruise control, a supportive high-backed seat, and simple mode changes.
Known limitation to consider
A key trade-off is the deck size. The X354 uses a 42-inch deck, which is narrower than many competitors. That makes mowing very large lawns slower.
Still, the machine offers a 4-year warranty and compatibility with a range of John Deere attachments. You can add items such as a 44-inch front blade or a snow blower to extend the mower’s usefulness into winter months.
Quick buying checklist for riding mowers
If you’re comparing models, these factors matter most:
- Deck width — wider decks cut more grass per pass.
- Durability and warranty — look for multi-year coverage.
- Cut quality — evenness, clumping, and discharge behavior.
- Comfort — seat design, ride smoothness, and controls.
- Accessory support — snow blowers, blades, and towing options.
- Price vs. performance — high-end models cost more but may last longer.
Cost and value: what to expect
The X354 is positioned toward the higher end of the market. Consumer Reports called out its price of around $5,100. For that investment, buyers get strong mowing performance and a flexible platform for attachments.
For many households, the decision will come down to yard size and how much value you place on comfort, reliability, and optional add-ons.
