Show summary Hide summary
- Why herringbone often wins over standard subway tile
- How Christina Haack applied herringbone to solve style conflicts
- When to choose herringbone: placement and scale tips
- Material choices and grout advice for a refined finish
- Budget, labor, and installation realities
- Design pairings that elevate a herringbone backsplash
When a newlywed pair clashed over kitchen style on Christina Haack’s renovation series, the designer sidestepped the classic white subway tile debate with a creative swap. She introduced a stone-look tile laid in a herringbone pattern that bridged both partners’ tastes. The choice softened the argument, elevated the room’s texture, and respected the existing color palette.
Why herringbone often wins over standard subway tile
Christina Haack reveals chic alternative to subway tile backsplashes
Affordable customizable window covers: ditch traditional curtains
Herringbone brings motion to a flat wall. Its diagonal layout creates visual rhythm. It reads as modern without being trendy. For homeowners who want interest but not extravagance, it hits the sweet spot.
- More texture: The zigzag pattern adds subtle depth and shadow.
- Better flow: It complements veining in stone counters and natural materials.
- Neutral but lively: Monochrome tiles in herringbone offer quiet elegance.
How Christina Haack applied herringbone to solve style conflicts
On an episode of Christina on the Coast, Haack faced a couple split between classic and contemporary tastes. The husband favored the timeless subway tile. The wife wanted something that felt less cookie-cutter. Haack chose a stone-look tile and rotated it into herringbone.
The result echoed the kitchen’s countertop veining and contrasted against blue cabinetry. It gave both partners what they wanted: a familiar neutral base with a fresh pattern. The herringbone layout satisfied two opposing styles without abandoning cohesion.
Repeat success across projects
Haack has used herringbone more than once to reconcile different aesthetic preferences. In another project she proposed the pattern for a shower to marry traditional finishes with coastal details. Clients often respond positively because herringbone can feel both classic and contemporary, depending on scale and material.
When to choose herringbone: placement and scale tips
Herringbone works as a full backsplash or as a focused accent. The scale of the tile affects the look dramatically.
- Small tiles create intricate, woven looks best for small walls.
- Large-format herringbone reads more modern and streamlined.
- Using it behind the stove or sink makes a purposeful focal point.
- Keeping other surfaces simple lets the pattern stand out.
Material choices and grout advice for a refined finish
Material changes the mood. Porcelain and ceramic are practical and durable. Natural stone adds warmth and veining. Glass can introduce sheen and reflect light.
- Porcelain/ceramic: Affordable, stain-resistant, great for kitchens.
- Stone-look porcelain: Mimics marble or travertine with lower upkeep.
- Glass tiles: Use sparingly to avoid visual overload.
Grout color also matters. A matching grout creates a continuous surface. A contrasting grout highlights the pattern. For a subtle, upscale appearance, choose grout one or two shades off from the tile.
Budget, labor, and installation realities
Herringbone takes more time to install than simple stacked or running-bond subway tile. The increased cuts and careful alignment raise labor costs. If budget is a concern, consider limiting herringbone to an accent area.
- Plan for extra tile and more labor hours.
- Ask your contractor about tile sizing to reduce waste.
- Prefabricated herringbone sheets can cut installation time.
Design pairings that elevate a herringbone backsplash
Pair herringbone with cabinetry and hardware that balance its movement.
- Blue or green cabinets: choose a warm stone tile to ground the color.
- Matte black hardware: adds contrast and a modern edge.
- Open shelving: display natural wood to complement the tile’s texture.
- Accent lighting: use undercabinet LEDs to enhance the pattern’s shadows.
